I. Introduction
a) Film: Animated TV series “Avatar: The Last Airbender”
b) Introduce idea of Bending—manipulative control of
elements (water, earth, fire, air)
c) Thesis: Most objects and actions NOT associated with
bending follow “our” natural laws of physics. Most objects associated with bending deliberately break
them.
II. Body
A. Falling, jumping and flying
1.
Realistic depictions
•Sokka
falls in a parabolic arc after stepping off a ledge
•Non-airbenders use gliders to fly
via thermal air patterns around the Northern Air Temple
•The Omashu mail system sled slows
out as it begins to slide down the chute/slope
2.
Non Realistic depictions
•Sokka’s
boomerang returns to him after it hits something
•It appears that Appa flies by
being lighter than air (floating), but it is established that he is heavy while
on the ground.
•Aang uses airbending to jump many
times higher than he should naturally be able to do (but follows parabolic
arcs, so this goes in both categories?)
B. Inertia
1.
Realistic depictions
•Characters are thrown against the
side of the boat when it turns sharply
•Aang bends the elements (rocks)
in an orbit around himself, and they fly straight away from him when he
releases them (following inertia)
2.
Non Realistic depictions
•The Library sinks into sand as if
it were water (the sand should be a balanced force opposing gravity at this
point)
•objects—particularly with earth
bending—accelerate instantaneously (without drag)
Characters traveling forward are
knocked sideways and stop, without continuing to move forward
C. A new “Natural Force” exists (Bending power)
1. Bending does not necessarily
follow the physics of our world, but does follow what we would consider logical
•Aang
uses Airbending to change his trajectory mid-air
•Toph
bends earth behind herself as a launching point to jump higher
•Heavier
objects (like large rocks and lots of water) are harder to lift
•Fire
exerts a physical force. Soldiers hit by a fireball are thrown back
•When Hama and Katara bend water
out of trees and plants, the plants are left shriveled by its absence
2. Counter-Example
Objects expand (gain mass) without
appropriate energy exchange (Eg. Aang’s glider, Jennamite rings). Even
considering bending, this is not logical
III. Conclusion
If you subtract the “magic” (bending) effects, this series
would have very believeable real-world physics, with just a few
inconsistencies.
No comments:
Post a Comment